S089 Intranet: latest QA findings (26 Sept 2026, evening)

Scope: all 48 functional requirements and the non-functional requirements in SRS v1.2.

Basis:


Headline

  1. The backend fixed 6 of the 11 open defects, including both security and governance ones (#11 section scoping, #17 self-approval). None of them count until UAT is redeployed and re-tested. That redeploy is now the single most useful action.
  2. Nine requirements are still blocked by one thing: no staff, policy or recognition data on UAT. The backend now reads HRMS directly, so this is DevOps setup, not code.
  3. No email has ever been delivered (#3). Three requirements can't pass until it is.
  4. The frontend has no open defects. It's built for all 48 requirements. What's left on our side is merging today's branch and re-testing.
  5. New risk: page speed. The staff portal's first download is 1.1 MB, which took 2.9 s on our connection against a 3 s home page target. Most of it comes from the shared component library.

Scorecard (48 functional requirements)

Status Count Change since 24 Sept
✅ Pass 15 none yet (6 more expected after the re-test)
🔧 Fixed, awaiting UAT re-test 6 new
❌ Defect 5 down from 11
⛔ Blocked (data or integration) 9 no change
🟡 Partly tested 7 no change
⚪ Not tested 6 no change

🔧 Fixed by the backend, awaiting re-test on UAT (6)

Req What was wrong Fix
B04-01, RBAC-02 Directorate owners could publish outside their directorate (#11, security) Section checked on every create, update and lifecycle action
C02-02 An approver could approve their own memo (#17, governance) Refused at submission and at decision
C06-01, RBAC-03 A delegate who is ordinary staff couldn't act (#18); dates only, no times Object-level check; exact start and end times. The frontend now has time pickers and a route for staff delegates to the queue
RBAC-04 Access review counted refused attempts as privileges used (#15) Only successful actions counted

❌ Still defective (5)

Req Issue Owner
C03-01 Status notifications: the resubmission bug (#1) is fixed, but no email arrives (#3) Backend, or DevOps if it's configuration
C05-01 Approved memos can't be distributed, because archival fails DevOps (see C05-02)
C05-02 Archival to Records (S003) fails (#2). The backend traced it to the environment: the background scheduler isn't running, or S003_ENABLED was switched on too early DevOps
D06-01 Audit events never reach S204 (#14). The payload is fixed; delivery is unverified Backend + DevOps
D07-01 Email and SMS delivery via S074 never proven (#3) Backend / DevOps

⛔ Blocked: no HR, policy or recognition data on UAT (9)

A01-03 (scoping by department and location), A03-01, A03-02, A03-03 (policy library), A04-01, A04-02, A04-03 (acknowledgements), B01-01 (directory), B02-01 (recognition).

All built on the frontend. Unblocking them needs, on UAT:

🟡 Partly tested (7)

Req Done Still to test or build
A02-03 Urgent banner Activate and deactivate; CCP can now deactivate (#16) SMS cross-post
C04-01 Resubmit v2 created and approved The "Edit & resubmit" button, live (memo 22)
D01-01 Knowledge spaces Frontend gaps fixed (#102): members can open restricted spaces, search links, attachments, categories, paging Backend: read replies, download attachments, moderation tools, and a hole where join skips the audience check
D03-01 Surveys Create, respond, close, anonymity Drafts, publish, totals
D05-01 Scheduling Archive and restore (restore now returns the prior state, #16) Scheduled publish, automatic expiry
D08-01 Onboarding Checklist admin New-starter view (needs HR start dates)
E06-01 Failure handling Health page, "could not be refreshed" notices Retry / sync now

⚪ Not tested (6)

B03-01 (quick links into other systems), C01-02 (malware gate, needs the EICAR test file), D04-01 (analytics figures), E03-01, E04-01 and E05-01 (all need email/SMS working first).


Non-functional requirements: what changed today

NFR Status Evidence
P1 Home page under 3 s ⚠️ At risk Staff portal: 1.1 MB of code and styles, 2.9 s just to download on our connection. Admin console: 2.4 MB, 3.4 s. Mostly fonts and images built into the component library
S3 TLS / encryption 🟡 TLS verified: UAT refuses TLS 1.1, serves 1.3, sends HSTS. Encryption at rest needs DevOps evidence
U3 Accessibility (WCAG 2.1 AA) 🟡 Automated scan of 24 staff and 30 console pages: every issue in our code fixed (mainly gold and grey text contrast). Remaining issues are in the component library. No screen-reader test yet
U4 Responsive ✅ (sample data) No page scrolls sideways at 320, 390 or 768 px in either app. To confirm on UAT with real data
— Compression and caching ✅ gzip on, hashed files cached for 1 year, index.html not cached, security headers present
P2, P3, R1, R2 ⚪ Not measured (search speed, load test, availability, backups)

Other findings from today

  1. Delegation will break when UAT gets the new backend, unless today's frontend branch is merged first. The backend renamed the fields (start_date → start_at). The branch sends both names, so it works with either version.

  2. The duty roster is back in scope and now reads the real endpoint. Its sample data is removed.

  3. Component library (@rfdtech/components 2.4.1, confirmed against npm):

    • unused components can't be dropped from bundles, so ~1.2 MB of HeroBanner photos ship everywhere;
    • fonts are embedded twice (~1.1 MB);
    • two <h1>s on every console page;
    • one sidebar contrast failure.

    Badge contrast is already fixed in 2.4.1, so the staff portal just needs upgrading from 2.1.0.


Open actions by owner

Owner Action Unblocks
Frontend (us) Merge feat/frontend-qa-pass before the UAT backend redeploy Delegation keeps working; #16, #18 and roster changes go live
Frontend Upgrade the staff portal to library 2.4.1; move the console off the vendored tarball Badge contrast; one library version
Frontend Re-test on UAT once redeployed (needs MFA codes) 6 "awaiting re-test" → pass
DevOps Redeploy UAT (backend with migrations, then frontend) All re-testing
DevOps Scheduler (Celery beat) running; the backend's setup checklist 9 blocked items, C05-01, C05-02
DevOps Evidence: availability, backups, encryption at rest R1, R2, S3
Backend Email (#3, #4, #5), blank survey response (#7), a mandatory policy on UAT (#9), confirm S204 delivery (#14) C03-01, D07-01, E03–E05, A04-01, D06-01
Backend Knowledge spaces: replies, attachment download, moderation, fix the join audience check D01-01
Manuel (library) Tree-shaking, fonts as files, AppHeaderTitle heading, sidebar token P1, U3

Supporting notes