Filed issues & PRs — UVL ecosystem reliability work
Findings are cross-referenced to the F# codes (detail in
../reliability/FINDINGS.md).
Totals: 20 open + 1 closed across 5 repos — FlamaPy analysis (z3/sat/bdd/fm metamodels) and the
UVL reference parser. Plus 4 fix PRs (3 ready, 1 to merge last).
FlamaPy — analysis stack
Semantic correctness (wrong answers on valid models)
| id |
finding |
status |
fix |
| z3_metamodel#3 |
F4 integer vs real division (12/8==1.5 → UNSAT) |
open |
PR #6 (green) |
| z3_metamodel#5 |
F1 avg denominator = declaring, not selected features |
open |
needs maintainer validation (see Questions) |
| flamapy#3 |
F3 forcing sat/bdd silently drops numeric constraints, reports exact |
open |
— (backend-selection footgun) |
Robustness / capability (errors on valid models)
| id |
finding |
status |
fix |
| z3_metamodel#4 |
F2 floor()/ceil() rejected ("Unsupported aggregation operator") |
open |
PR #7 (green) |
| z3_metamodel#9 |
F9 string literal with . mis-resolved as Feature.Attribute |
open |
PR #10 (green) |
| z3_metamodel#8 |
F5 opaque Z3 error on a malformed 2-arg aggregate |
open |
— (semantics clarified, see Questions) |
| bdd_metamodel#39 |
F6 BDD backend rejects dotted/namespaced names; auto inherits it |
open |
— (dep-rooted; sat/z3 handle it) |
| fm_metamodel#108 |
model with no features section crashes the reader (AttributeError) |
open |
— |
Semantics questions (need maintainer / spec decision)
| id |
question |
status |
| z3_metamodel#5 |
Is the avg denominator meant to be # selected bearers (JSS Table 1) or # declaring? |
open — likely a real deviation |
| z3_metamodel#8 |
2-arg aggregate semantics when args are typed features |
open — answered by uvl-parser#50: agg(att, root), use + for values ⇒ the model was malformed |
Tooling / conformance
| id |
what |
status |
| z3_metamodel#11 |
proposal: reference-oracle conformance regression suite |
open |
| PR z3_metamodel#12 |
the conformance suite (ground truth) |
open — MERGE LAST; red by design on the 3 bugs above until #6/#7/#10 land |
Resolved
| id |
finding |
status |
| bdd_metamodel#37 |
BDD overcounts a [0..0] group |
closed — fixed upstream (no longer reproduces) |
UVL reference parser (Universal-Variability-Language/uvl-parser)
Parser conformance (cross-implementation divergences / robustness)
| id |
issue |
status |
| #77 |
Python parser RecursionError on valid deeply-nested attributes |
open |
| #78 |
Java & JS reject trailing spaces at EOF (Python accepts) |
open |
| #79 |
Python rejects a feature after an inline block comment |
open |
| #80 |
JS rejects a full-line // comment before group children |
open |
| #85 |
Python parser UnicodeDecodeError on any non-ASCII character |
open |
| #86 |
Java rejects a /* … */ comment on a line of its own |
open |
| #87 |
[1] in an attribute is lexed as a cardinality (can't write a 1-int vector) |
open |
| #88 |
JS raises no lexer errors, so it accepts files the others reject |
open |
Packaging / meta
| id |
issue |
status |
| #89 |
uvlparser installs main/test_grammar as top-level modules; pins old ANTLR |
open |
| #90 |
License mismatch (LICENSE LGPL-3.0 vs setup.py GPLv3 vs pom.xml MIT) |
open |
| #91 |
make python_parser/js_parser fail when the path contains a space |
open |